I tried everything I could think of, including turning off the AT&T gateway’s wifi. The connectivity of the AX1800 is about 50% behind 2 walls and the speed is maybe a tenth of what it is right next to it. I did not attempt to individually test 5Ghz vs 2.4Ghz but if one was better than the other, I would have expected my devices to switch to it. While the AX1800 might work in an apartment, I just could not make it work in my house.
I truly love pcwrt. If there is a more powerful router someone can recommend that I could load the firmware on, I’d be happy to try it.