The Torch Router started out as a Kickstarter campaign in October 2015, and started shipping in October 2016. On May 9, 2017 some Torch users received emails informing them that Torch ceased operations. On May 31, 2017 it went completely dark, to the dismay of many.
Since we also offer a parental control solution on the WiFi router, we were often asked to compare our product with other competing products. Usually we ask people to arrive at their own conclusions.
One question that came up many times was “cloud” vs. “non-cloud”, which is better? Since “cloud” is the “in” word these days, many people assume that cloud routers are more advanced, and therefore, better. Unfortunately, more often than not, “cloud” is a burden rather than an advantage.
There are at least three reasons “cloud” can work to your disadvantage:
These concerns were proven valid when Skydog was bought up, and again today when Torch shuts down. They are the same reasons we designed the pcWRT as a standalone router from the very beginning. If, for reasons beyond our control, our business goes belly up, you’d still have a fully functional pcWRT router.
BTW, we do offer cloud based remote control capability. But that is offered as an add-on, a convenience feature, not something that the router depends on in order for it to function. That is an essential difference.
You’re absolutely right about the security! Torch actually talks back to their server unencrypted! Unbelievable! Maybe it’s not such a bad thing that Torch died after all.
That was a surprise. It was a gross negligence indeed. When security is concerned, even subtle mistakes can have real consequences.
Torch – a router designed to be seen. Now “to be seen” only. What a pity.
Looks like both Torch and pcWRT make use of OpenWRT. Is it possible to run pcWRT on my Torch router? Just asking…
In theory, it is possible. It is a pity to see such a good piece of hardware to be dumped to the trash can. We’d like to help out but are afraid that there’s not enough interest among the Torch users.
I found this post which gives hope:
https://www.pcwrt.com/2017/08/how-to-flash-the-torch-router-with-pcwrt/